📅 Monthly Basis

The Best Volunteer Management Systems (VMS) for Nonprofits in 2025

A Comprehensive Analysis

Introduction

Volunteer engagement lies at the heart of nonprofit effectiveness, from driving mission-critical programs to scaling community impact. Efficient management of volunteer operations—ensuring the right people are recruited, scheduled, tracked, and engaged—has become a key success factor for organizations both large and small. In 2025, a robust Volunteer Management System (VMS) is more than an administrative aid; it's a strategic asset that can amplify fundraising, deepen stakeholder connections, and deliver tangible impact analytics.

This report provides a deeply researched overview of top VMS solutions available to U.S.-based nonprofits—especially those serving small to mid-sized constituencies, such as organizations in Copley, Ohio. The following analysis features a structured breakdown of the leading platforms, comparison tables summarizing features and pricing, detailed pros and cons, illustrative use-cases, and an emphasis on modern requirements like mobile access and CRM integration. Both free and paid options are covered, with a focus on real-world suitability, strengths, and potential pitfalls for today's nonprofit sector.

The Evolving Volunteer Management Software Market

The VMS market has undergone rapid transformation, shaped by three large currents:

  1. Digital Transformation in Nonprofits: Mobile technology adoption, online engagement, fundraising integration, and self-service tools have become necessities for efficient volunteer operations.
  2. Data-Driven Impact and Compliance: Grantors, donors, and boards increasingly expect clear reporting on volunteer contributions, necessitating accurate hour-tracking, skills inventories, and performance analytics.
  3. Integrated Supporter Experience: Volunteers are often also donors, event attendees, or advocates. The demand for unified platforms or seamless integration with major CRMs and fundraising tools has soared.

The economic impact of volunteering is substantial: in 2024, a single volunteer hour was valued at $33.49 by Independent Sector, with Americans contributing an estimated $123 billion in labor annually.

Features and Selection Criteria for the Modern VMS

Whether a nonprofit is selecting its first VMS or considering a switch, the following key features have emerged as must-haves:

  • Volunteer Database and Profiles: Detailed tracking of contact info, skills, interests, availabilities, onboarding status, and engagement history.
  • Online Recruitment and Onboarding: Customizable application portals, screening tools (e.g., background checks), and digital onboarding workflows.
  • Shift/Event Scheduling: Flexible, self-service sign-ups for events, recurring shifts, or last-minute needs. Group registration and permissions for team leaders.
  • Time Tracking: Accurate and granular hour logging (mobile app, kiosk, web portal); milestone tracking and recognition.
  • Communication Tools: Mass email/text, automated reminders, targeted outreach by segment, and volunteer self-service control.
  • Event and Opportunity Management: Support for complex, multi-site events, recurring roles, and analytics.
  • Reporting and Analytics: Impact dashboards, grant compliance, customizable exports, real-time insights into engagement and attrition.
  • Mobile Access: Fully responsive portals or native apps for mobile-first volunteers and managers.
  • Integrations: Seamless data flow with core nonprofit tools—Salesforce, Blackbaud, donor CRMs, fundraising platforms, Google Apps, and others.

Beyond these essentials, organizations may value gamification/badging for motivation, digital waivers for compliance, or specialty integrations (e.g., background checks, fundraising/donation conversion).

Comparison of Leading Volunteer Management Systems

Below is a summary comparison table for prominent VMS offerings in 2025, synthesizing findings on mobile support, integrations, cost, and unique advantages:

Platform Event Coord. Time Tracking Mobile Access CRM Integration Free Version Starting Price Best For
VolunteerHub Yes Yes Yes Blackbaud, Salesforce No $1,716/year Small–Large orgs needing CRM
Better Impact Yes Yes Yes (App) Limited (API, not native) No ~ $500+/year Small–Mid orgs, cross-dept.
CERVIS Yes Yes Yes Salesforce, Blackbaud eTapestry No $100/month Small–Mid orgs, scalable
Rosterfy Yes Yes Yes Salesforce, Blackbaud No $7,000/year Large/multi-site, automation
Track It Forward Limited Yes Yes (App) No (CSV/Zapier) Yes $12–$30/month Small orgs, schools, time-tracking
Volgistics Yes Yes Yes (Portal) None (Email, Mailchimp) No $9–$100+/month Small–Large, complex tracking
VOMO Yes Yes Yes (App) Virtuous, Salesforce No $99.99/month Small–Mid orgs, fundraising-link
POINT + Funraise Yes Yes Yes (App) Funraise, Donorbox Yes Free core / $99/mo Pro Small–Mid, donor-vol. conversion
SignUpGenius Basic Limited Yes Zapier, NonProfitEasy Yes $8.99+/month Small orgs, quick scheduling
Bugle Yes Yes Yes Zapier Yes Free / $24.42/employee/yr Small–Mid orgs, unlimited vols
Mobilize Yes Yes (integr.) Yes NGP VAN (EveryAction) Starter $500/month Advocacy, campaigns, mid/large

Key: "Event Coord." = Event Coordination; "Time Tracking": Tracks hours/milestones; "CRM Integration": Includes prominent donor/volunteer CRM integrations. Pricing accurate as of Aug 2025, may vary by options, seat count, or modules.

Detailed Platform Analyses

VolunteerHub

Features: VolunteerHub stands out for comprehensive event management, group and individual registration, custom-branded landing pages, powerful scheduling (self-service), waiver management, mobile optimization, robust reporting, and gamification/recognition tools. Direct integrations with Blackbaud (Raiser's Edge, eTapestry, Luminate), Salesforce, and Zapier support seamless data unification. Additional features include SSO, waitlists, automated communications, Google Analytics integration, and a QR-code check-in kiosk.

Pricing:

  • Plus: $143/month (up to 1,000 active volunteers)
  • Pro: $288/month (up to 2,500 volunteers)
  • Enterprise: Custom (>2,500 volunteers)
  • (Annual billing, setup fees apply)

Pros:

  • Powerfully supports all core volunteer workflows for organizations of all sizes.
  • Strong compliance, fund development, and HR reporting features.
  • Advanced integrations (including bidirectional Salesforce–Blackbaud via Omatic/Lingk).
  • Unlimited non-active vols, unlimited site admins.

Cons:

  • Price and setup may be high for very small, budget-constrained organizations.
  • Advanced modules (e.g., waivers, forms) can increase cost.

Suitability and Use-Cases: Ideal for organizations requiring coordination across multiple events/departments, those reliant on grant and donor reporting, and anyone needing seamless donor-volunteer data flow. Used by museums, food banks, health sector, and multisite programs in the U.S.

Better Impact (Volunteer Impact)

Features: A collection of cloud-based tools, including volunteer onboarding, scheduling with advanced permissions and role assignments, in-depth time tracking, application portals, self-scheduling, online training modules (with quizzes), communication (email/SMS/messaging), and recognition via milestone badges. Multi-department configuration and permissions are robust. Some API integration and background check tools exist (Sterling, Salesforce, Microsoft).

Pricing:

  • Foundation (up to 500 volunteers): Under $500/year
  • Growth (up to 1,000): Contact for quote
  • Impact (unlimited): Enterprise pricing
  • (Sliding scale per number of active volunteers; modules a la carte; $288/year and up mentioned in some sources)

Pros:

  • Widely praised for ease of use—even for tech-hesitant volunteers and admins.
  • Strong for organizations that need complex scheduling, multi-site/departmental controls, and onboarding pipelines.
  • Affordable for many small to mid-sized orgs.
  • Excellent mobile app.

Cons:

  • Full CRM integration is limited (via API, not native to Salesforce/Blackbaud).
  • Additional fees for advanced training and support; reporting flexibility can be improved.
  • Some onboarding form and automation/reporting limitation.

Suitability: Best for small-to-mid-sized nonprofits that prioritize user-friendly experience, online training/onboarding, and role-based scheduling across departments. Highly adopted in community organizations, hospitals, and charities. International usage includes strong U.S. client base.

CERVIS

Features: Offers online volunteer registration, self-service shift/event signups, scheduling with automated waitlists, hour tracking, group/event management, customizable profiles, geofencing check-ins, digital waivers, and automatic text/email reminders. CRM integrations include Blackbaud (Raiser’s Edge NXT, eTapestry), and Salesforce. Custom reporting, permission controls, multi-site management. Kiosk and mobile support.

Pricing:

  • Basic: $25/month (limited features)
  • Standard: $100/month (multi-site, CRM integration)
  • Premier: $175/month (full set: waitlists, SMS, APIs, mobile)
  • Enterprise: Custom
  • (Monthly or annual; setup fee may apply; 30-day guarantee)

Pros:

  • Flexible, affordable for small/mid-sized orgs.
  • Powerful admin controls and customizability, strong support reputation.
  • Real-time scheduling is efficient.

Cons:

  • May get complex for very large orgs (>5,000 volunteers).
  • Initial setup can be involved; reporting/custom forms less flexible for deeply customized workflows.
  • Lacks landing page/event marketing customization.

Suitability: Ideal for smaller or mid-sized U.S. nonprofits (social service agencies, local chapters), multi-department management, and organizations needing to consolidate paper/Excel workflows.

Rosterfy

Features: Rosterfy targets large, complex, or multi-location organizations, offering full-spectrum volunteer lifecycle automation (recruitment, onboarding, compliance, scheduling, communication, reward/gamification), powerful automations (75% of admin can be automated), mobile app, online training, group/event/role-based onboarding, robust reporting, multi-level permissioning and group administration. Integration includes Salesforce, Blackbaud, Google, Microsoft, HubSpot, Adobe, and over 50 additional partners.

Pricing:

  • Standard annual subscription starting at $7,000/year (usage-based, scales by seat/volunteer count)
  • Custom enterprise plans; multi-site/department options.

Pros:

  • Extremely configurable and scalable for high-volume organizations.
  • Advanced automations, group workflows, and integration capability; accessible mobile app for all roles.
  • Exceptional customer support and ongoing development.

Cons:

  • High learning curve and cost for small teams.
  • Initial setup/integration can require heavy IT/admin investment.

Suitability: Best for larger cities, multi-chapter orgs, universities, faith-based multi-site, and orgs managing compliance/regulation requirements at scale (e.g., international events, campaigns, federations).

Track It Forward

Features: A time-tracking-centric program: volunteer self-service hour logging, event sign-ups/RSVPs, milestone/badge tracking, mobile app and web portal, shift scheduling, real-time approval, custom fields, reporting (CSV/export), administrator controls, reminders/blasts. Widget can be placed on nonprofit site for integration.

Pricing:

  • Free basic plan for core hour tracking
  • Paid options from $12–$30/month; additional admins, features, custom modules raise price

Pros:

  • User-friendly and affordable for even the smallest orgs.
  • Strong support for school programs, service clubs, honor societies, faith groups—where hours needing audit/reporting is primary requirement.
  • Supports hour approval workflows, milestone celebrations.

Cons:

  • Less robust for full event scheduling or advanced integrations.
  • Reporting/export can require manual collation for more detailed analytics.
  • Interface is basic and lacks modern social/mobile flair.

Suitability: Ideal for schools, volunteer clubs, organizations tracking required/community service, and nonprofits managing under 500 volunteers who mostly need simple, mobile hour tracking. Not suited for enterprise-level scale or multi-program event management.

Volgistics

Features: One of the longest-running VMS providers (since 1980s/early web): customizable database fields, self-service portal (VicNet), touchscreen check-in kiosk (VicTouch), online applications and directories, hour tracking, recurring and one-off event scheduling, recognition tools, communication, automated reminders, robust reporting, group/departmental management, and secure data handling. Mobile self-service for volunteers (no admin app).

Pricing:

  • Entry at $9/month (scales with volunteer/feature volume, tiered up to $100+/month)
  • Free trial; no hidden setup or support fees； à la carte features can raise final price.

Pros:

  • Highly customizable to suit diverse nonprofit needs; strong for hospitals, museums, food banks, animal shelters.
  • Affordable starting price; no phone support but very responsive email help.

Cons:

  • Outdated UI; reporting/automation could require heavy admin intervention.
  • No CRM/fundraising platform integration; multi-site coordination requires configuration.
  • Steep learning curve for new users or those seeking modern UX.

Suitability: Well-suited for medium and large orgs, especially those valuing granular hour tracking, volunteer segmentation, and multi-department collaboration without needing deep fundraising/donor integration.

VOMO

Features: Comprehensive solution for event management, shift scheduling, volunteer database, dynamic communication (mass text/email), digital waivers, mobile check-in, reporting, integrated marketplace posting (expanded event exposure), and direct CRM/fundraising connection to Virtuous, Salesforce, Zapier, and others.

Pricing:

  • Standard plan: $99.99/month (contact for higher volumes); free trial available

Pros:

  • Integrates with Virtuous CRM for donor-volunteer link
  • Highly mobile-optimized; forms, reminders, check-ins all app-driven
  • Event marketplace functionality increases volunteer recruitment

Cons:

  • Clunky/app learning curve cited in recent reviews; some user dissatisfaction with setup complexity
  • Payments final/non-refundable; limited group setup features
  • Limited documentation for more advanced CRM integrations

Suitability: Nonprofits seeking to connect volunteers and donors, needing public exposure for events, and prioritizing mobile event management. Ideal for mid-sized orgs focusing on hybrid volunteer/fundraising strategies.

POINT and Funraise Integration

Features: POINT offers a free, user-friendly volunteer engagement platform supporting event management, time tracking, mobile sign-ups, check-in stations, website widgets, and strong communication and reporting tools. The Funraise integration brings in donor/volunteer unification: donations can be collected within POINT, and volunteer action is reflected in Funraise for nuanced supporter analytics. Easy to embed donation forms, automatically sync volunteer hours and profiles to the CRM.

Pricing:

  • POINT Core: Free with unlimited volunteers
  • Pro: $99/month, adds digital kiosks and advanced admin features
  • (Funraise as a full fundraising CRM is priced separately)

Pros:

  • Robust free tier; unlimited volunteers/admins
  • Clean, modern app/UX; highly rated mobile experience
  • Integration auto-syncs hours and donor/volunteer data; good for small organizations scaling up
  • Simple, fast deployment

Cons:

  • Some advanced reporting and automation behind Pro paywall
  • Integration is evolving—less established than legacy systems
  • API integration with platforms beyond Funraise/Donorbox limited

Suitability: Best for smaller, tech-forward nonprofits wanting quick setup, strong mobile workflows, unified donor-volunteer communication, and budget-friendly options. Particularly valuable for new orgs or volunteer-driven programs aiming to grow to integrated fundraising.

SignUpGenius

Features: A web-first system specializing in easy event and shift sign-up forms, full mobile access, self-service registration, reminders/notifications, basic reporting, and quick duplicate/edit tools for recurring opportunities. Integration through Zapier/nonprofit-specific CRMs is supported. Advanced tiers offer expanded capacity, custom branding, and priority support.

Pricing:

  • Free tier (ad-supported, limited customization/volume)
  • Paid tiers: Silver ($8.99/month), Gold ($22.49/month), Platinum ($44.99/month); Enterprise from $1,299/year
  • (Annually billed; volume of shifts, custom emails, etc. increase with plan)

Pros:

  • Extremely accessible; less than 15-minute deployment for most users
  • Intuitive UI, high user satisfaction for simple scheduling/notifications
  • Useful for one-off events, schools, churches, and clubs
  • Excellent support and knowledgebase

Cons:

  • Reporting, customization, and donor/volunteer CRM integration limited
  • Ads in free plan; minor mobile UI issues; advanced features only in paid
  • No advanced hour-tracking or milestone logging

Suitability: Ideal for small groups needing event/shift signup—boosters, K-12 schools, faith orgs, small teams running food drives or community events. Not recommended for orgs needing multi-year impact tracking or CRM integration.

Bugle

Features: A newer entrant focusing on feature-rich event management: unlimited volunteers/admins, digital event check-in/out, customized forms/waivers, automated communications (email, SMS), embeddable event calendars, analytics (paid), and unlimited chapter management (premium). Crowdfunding integration boosts fundraising at events and reporting capabilities.

Pricing:

  • Community Plan: Free, full event management for unlimited users
  • Premium: $24.42 per W-2 employee annually; adds analytics/CRM data transfer via Zapier

Pros:

  • Unlimited seats/volunteers at no cost via Community Plan
  • Extremely rapid onboarding (less than 6 minutes for first event)
  • Crowdfunding unique among free/ultra-low-cost VMS
  • Suitable for organizations with multiple chapters

Cons:

  • No background check integration
  • Analytics and CRM integration are paid features; limited advanced donor/vol. tracking
  • Survey tools not built-in

Suitability: Small-to-mid-sized nonprofits (esp. those with many local event managers); ideal for community organizations launching events and needing to maximize turnout with minimal budget overhead.

Mobilize

Features: Mobilize specializes in advocacy and campaign organizing—supports large-scale event deployment (hybrid/virtual or in-person), RSVP management, shift scheduling, SMS/email reminders, "bring-a-friend" and cross-promotion, feedback surveys, real-time analytics, custom branding, and deep integration with political tools (NGP VAN/EveryAction, ActBlue, Google Analytics, PayPal, Salesforce).

Pricing:

  • Starter: Free (5 users, 5 events)
  • Small orgs: Starting at $500/month
  • Large orgs: $2,000/month+
  • (Discounts and negotiation possible for small political/advocacy orgs)

Pros:

  • Outstanding event scaling/outreach, suited for mass mobilization
  • Automated communications cut "flake rates" (no-shows); granular analytics
  • Large peer-network for event exposure and co-promotion
  • Integrated with NGP VAN and major campaign CRMs

Cons:

  • Monthly cost often too high for small nonprofits not engaged in ongoing campaigns
  • Reporting/filters could improve; email/text customization limited
  • Weak hour tracking; not best for year-round volunteer lifecycle management

Suitability: Political, advocacy, union, and large membership groups needing national reach or repeated event orchestration; not ideal for single-chapter/single-event management unless at high volume. Some use for mid-sized U.S. nonprofits with aggressive expansion goals.

Additional Notable Systems

  • Bloomerang Volunteer (formerly InitLive): Top choice for organizations already committed to the Bloomerang CRM ecosystem; deep integration between donor and volunteer records, strong mobile tools. Pricing starts at $119/month, scaling with volunteer base size.
  • Galaxy Digital (Get Connected): Focused on community centers, coalitions, and universities needing to coordinate among multiple orgs, with good mobile tools, team signups, and customizable group workflows.
  • VolunteerMatters, Little Green Light, HandsOn Connect, Giveffect: Candidates for orgs with specific multi-function CRM, fundraising, or grants management needs; pricing and suitability vary.

Pricing Models and Budget Considerations

VMS costs range dramatically. Free or ultra-low-cost solutions like POINT, Bugle, Track It Forward, and SignUpGenius address basic scheduling, hour tracking, and communication—well-suited for small or niche orgs. Midmarket options often run $600–$2,500/year, while enterprise and custom solutions (e.g., Rosterfy, large-scale VolunteerHub) can start at $7,000+/year, scaling by administrator roles, record count, or module usage.

Key budgeting tips:

  • Volume scaling: Many platforms charge based on active/archived volunteers under management, so accurately project your active base.
  • Integration costs: API, CRM, advanced reporting, and waivers may incur added fees even in mid-tier or enterprise plans.
  • Training and support: Check if onboarding support is included; some (notably Better Impact) charge for step-by-step implementation.

Platform Integrations and Ecosystem Considerations

For organizations using robust donor management or fundraising platforms (Salesforce Nonprofit Success Pack, Blackbaud Raiser's Edge/Luminate, Virtuous, DonorPerfect, Funraise, Donorbox), choosing a VMS with native or API-based integration delivers a unified supporter record—critical for maximizing long-term engagement and segmenting communications.

Example integrations:

  • Salesforce ↔ Blackbaud: Omatic and Lingk platforms provide bidirectional sync, eliminating silos in donor/volunteer data, which improves reporting, communication, and stewardship efforts.
  • Funraise + POINT: Volunteer impact (hours, last activity) is auto-synced to supporter profiles, and donation forms can be embedded directly into the volunteer sign-up portal.

Before selecting a VMS, verify the exact integration capabilities with your preferred CRM/fundraising system, factoring in potential custom development or middleware solutions for unique workflows.

Selecting the Right VMS: Suitability by Organization Size

Small Nonprofits (up to ~500 volunteers):

  • Best fit free/low-cost: POINT, Bugle, Track It Forward, SignUpGenius
  • Best fit paid/low-mid: Better Impact, Volgistics, VolunteerLocal
  • Emphasize: Fast deployment, ease-of-use for tech-hesitant, cost transparency

Mid-sized Nonprofits (~500–2,500 volunteers):

  • Best fit: VolunteerHub (Plus/Pro), CERVIS (Standard/Premier), Rosterfy, Volgistics (higher tiers), VOMO, Bloomerang Volunteer (if CRM alignment), Civic Champs (for mobile-first)
  • Emphasize: Onboarding automation, team management, robust event coordination, compliance

Large/Complex Organizations (>2,500 volunteers, multi-site):

  • Best fit: VolunteerHub (Enterprise), Rosterfy, Get Connected, Golden Volunteer, VolunteerMatters
  • Emphasize: Scalability, departmentalization, permission controls, bi-directional data integrations, advanced KPI reporting

Conclusion and Recommendations

The landscape of volunteer management systems in 2025 is both broad and deep. For nonprofits in the United States—especially those with small to mid-sized teams—VMS selection should be driven by both today's operational demands and tomorrow's growth ambitions.

  • Rapidly scaling or integration-focused orgs: VolunteerHub and Rosterfy stand out for enterprise readiness and partnership with donor CRMs.
  • Budget-conscious orgs: POINT, Bugle, Track It Forward, and SignUpGenius deliver crucial features at low/no cost.
  • CRM-centric organizations: Favor solutions with direct sync to Blackbaud, Salesforce, or Virtuous; VolunteerHub, Bloomerang Volunteer, and VOMO are strong picks.
  • Mobile-dominant teams: Better Impact, Civic Champs, and POINT excel.
  • Multi-branch or chapter-based nonprofits: Rosterfy and Bugle offer unique capabilities for distributed leadership and consolidated analytics.

Ultimately, the "best" VMS depends on your organization's specific structure, priorities, volunteer/donor overlap, and technical landscape. The diversity of modern platforms ensures that every nonprofit—whether managing a few events a year or operating dozens of simultaneous programs—can find a system that delivers both operational efficiency and strategic insight.